2 result(s) tagged “JFK”

Five Minutes: JFK

audio.png

'JFK': Don't trust what you can't seeWhen we say that a movie is more style than substance, we typically mean it derisively.

Oliver Stone’s JFK has a ton of stuff — with the director’s cut running nearly three and a half hours — that was mistaken for its substance. But the meat of the movie is its style, because it’s the fuel that made the film so combustible.

The movie was greeted with contentious debate upon its release in 1991, but Stone’s critics and supporters completely missed the boat by arguing about facts, theories, and cover-ups. JFK works not as an argument but as a style of argument — sly and forceful in equal measure — and an exemplar of contemporary propaganda.

I’m about 15 years late to this party, but I’ve always planned to write a lengthy piece on my love for Oliver Stone’s JFK. My point would simply be that whatever its failings as a credible history (or even a viable alternative history), JFK excels as propaganda, and should be studied for that reason. In a 1993 essay in The Atlantic, Edward Jay Epstein does a good job explaining Stone’s methods:

“The fictional O’Keefe’s story is supported by Ferrie’s fictional confession, which is then given weight by Ferrie’s fictional murder by the fictional bald-headed Cuban introduced in O’Keefe’s story. Since ... Oliver Stone’s audience is not apprised of the substitutions of fiction for fact, this cross-corroboration makes plausible ... the New Orleans plot.”
The irony is that the essay is intended as a tearing apart of Stone and his film. (Beware that the Internet version of Epstein’s article is rife with typos, making infrequent sentences incomprehensible.)

1

I'm a LAMB

  • bt_assoc_grey.jpg

Recent Entries

  • Box Office Power Rankings: November 14-16, 2008

    Does it make sense to get out of the way of a certain blockbuster? Or should studios try to tap into a market being unserved ...

  • Fixed Favorites

    For the first time since fall 2006, I updated the 100 Favorite Movies feature of Culture Snob. Thirteen movies were added, and 29 went away. ...

  • Box Office Power Rankings: November 7-9, 2008

    It was odd to read these two things within a few minutes of each other: On Role Models: “[T]he kind of movie you don’t see ...

  • Box Office Power Rankings: October 31-November 2, 2008

    The consensus that Kevin Smith’s Zack and Miri Make a Porno and Clint Eastwood’s Changeling were poor performers — the weakest Halloween weekend in a ...

  • Thomson Twinge

    “Have You Seen ... ?” David Thomson’s “Have You Seen ... ?” A Personal Introduction to 1,000 Films is the book that I’d been waiting ...

Most-Read Entries

Recent Comments

  • I don’t disagree, but I think there can still be subtlety in a character with a hard surface. The performance might indeed be honest, but ...

  • I think the reason Taylor Hackford directed Jennifer Jason Leigh to deliver through clenched teeth is that her character, after years of abuse, no longer ...

  • Kudos on your inclusion of “The Texas Chainsaw Massacre.” This film always seems to be criticized more and more as it ages. However, its ...

  • TRANSIT is one of best shorts I ever seen. Piet Kroon and Ian Harvey are together in a new movie: “Not the End of the ...

  • Two reasons I revere Martin Scorsese are: The tempo of his films and his compassion for characters on the fringe. His love of film ...

    Mike Reid
    My Movie Life
Close